• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

McCarter & English Logo

  • People
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Our Firm
    • Leadership Team
    • Social Justice
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Pro Bono
    • Client Service Values
  • Join Us
    • Lawyers
    • Summer Associates
    • Patent Professionals
    • Professional Staff
    • Job Openings
  • Locations
    • Boston
    • Philadelphia
    • East Brunswick
    • Stamford
    • Hartford
    • Trenton
    • Newark
    • Washington, DC
    • New York
    • Wilmington
  • Share

Share

Browse Alphabetically:

  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • E
  • F
  • G
  • H
  • I
  • J
  • K
  • L
  • M
  • N
  • O
  • P
  • Q
  • R
  • S
  • T
  • U
  • V
  • W
  • X
  • Y
  • Z
  • All
Bankruptcy, Restructuring & Litigation
Blockchain, Smart Contracts & Digital Currencies
Business Litigation
Cannabis
Coronavirus Resource Center
Corporate
Crisis Management
Cybersecurity & Data Privacy
Delaware Corporate, LLC & Partnership Law
Design, Fashion & Luxury
E-Discovery & Records Management
Energy & Utilities
Environment & Energy
Financial Institutions
Government Affairs
Government Contracts & Global Trade
Government Investigations & White Collar Defense
Healthcare
Immigration
Impact Investing
Insurance Recovery, Litigation & Counseling
Intellectual Property
Labor & Employment Law
Life Sciences
Manufacturing
Products Liability, Mass Torts & Consumer Class Actions
Proptech
Public Finance 
Real Estate
Renewable Energy
Sports & Entertainment
Tax & Employee Benefits 
Technology Transactions
Transportation, Logistics & Supply Chain Management
Trusts, Estates & Private Clients 
Venture Capital & Emerging Growth Companies
  • Broadcasts
  • Events
  • News
  • Publications
  • View All Insights
Search By:
Insights News Open Stack
Main image for The Court of Chancery Applies DCF to Determine the Fair Value of Trussway Holdings
Publications|Alert

The Court of Chancery Applies DCF to Determine the Fair Value of Trussway Holdings

Delaware Law Update

3.19.2019

Kendall Hoyd and Silver Spur Capital Partners, LP v. Trussway Holdings, LLC, C.A. No. 2017-0260-VCG

In the Delaware Court of Chancery’s decision on February 28, 2019, Vice Chancellor Sam Glasscock relies on the discounted cash-flow (DCF) methodology to find the fair value of the shares of Houston-based manufacturer Trussway Holdings LLC to be $236.52 per share, which lands between the $387.82 valuation offered by the petitioner and the $225.92 valuation offered by the respondent company.

Case Background

Trussway’s board of directors approved a merger in December 2016, at which time Trussway and its subsidiaries were converted into limited-liability companies. The company’s two minority stockholders sought appraisal pursuant to 8 Del. C. 262 in the Court of Chancery shortly thereafter, although one settled with Trussway prior to trial.

The remaining petitioner agreed with the respondent on the value of the company’s assets and liabilities. The primary point of dispute was the value of Trussway’s wholly owned subsidiary, Trussway Industries, Inc. (“TII”). The petitioner’s expert valued TII through a DCF analysis based on a set of nine-year projections developed by TII management (the “management projections”), a comparable companies analysis, and a precedent transaction analysis, with 60% weight afforded to the DCF. Notably, the petitioner’s expert added a “1% risk premium to WACC to allow for the reduced predictability of performance in the outer four years.”

The respondent’s expert used a variation of the Income Approach, applying 25% weight to a DCF analysis based on the management projections, but assigning 75% weight to an alternate DCF analysis based on a modified version of five-year projections. The respondent argued against wholesale reliance on the management projections given that they had been created for use in a TII sales process and were “based on strategic initiatives…which had not commenced as of the merger.”

The Court of Chancery Decision

The Court of Chancery rejected market approaches for valuing TII, finding that the “supposed ‘comparable companies’ are too divergent from TII, in terms of size, public status, and products, to form meaningful analogs for valuation purposes.” Turning to DCF, the court found the management projections to be management’s best estimate of TII’s future performance. The court was not troubled by the inclusion of the strategic initiatives on the ground that they formed part of TII’s operative reality at the time of the merger.

Of more concern to the Vice Chancellor was “management’s ability to accurately predict corporate performance nine years out.” The court declined to adopt the petitioner’s 1% risk premium and opted for the respondent’s blended approach, placing 50% weight on a DCF derived from the management projections and 50% weight on a second DCF derived from the same management forecasts with a terminal period beginning after a more standard five years.

Key Takeaways

The court’s analysis provides helpful insight into the meaning of “operative reality” as used in the Delaware appraisal statute and underscores the utility of the DCF methodology in the context of a private company valuation.

sidebar

pdfemail

Related People

Media item: Sarah E. Delia
Sarah E. Delia

Associate

Related Services

Delaware Corporate, LLC & Partnership Law
Subscribe to our Insights
McCarter & English, LLP
Copyright © 2021 McCarter & English, LLP. All Rights Reserved.
  • Login
  • Attorney Advertising
  • Privacy
  • Awards Methodology
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Sitemap

The McCarter & English, LLP website is for informational purposes only. We do not provide legal advice on this website. We can provide legal advice only to our clients in specific inquiries that they address to us. If you are interested in becoming a client, please contact us, but do not send any information about your specific legal question. We cannot serve as your lawyers until we establish an attorney-client relationship, which can occur only after we follow procedures within our firm and after we agree to the terms of the representation.

Accept Cancel