• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

McCarter & English Logo

  • People
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Our Firm
    • Leadership Team
    • Social Justice
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Pro Bono
    • Client Service Values
  • Join Us
    • Lawyers
    • Summer Associates
    • Patent Professionals
    • Professional Staff
    • Job Openings
  • Locations
    • Boston
    • Philadelphia
    • East Brunswick
    • Stamford
    • Hartford
    • Trenton
    • Newark
    • Washington, DC
    • New York
    • Wilmington
  • Share

Share

Browse Alphabetically:

  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • E
  • F
  • G
  • H
  • I
  • J
  • K
  • L
  • M
  • N
  • O
  • P
  • Q
  • R
  • S
  • T
  • U
  • V
  • W
  • X
  • Y
  • Z
  • All
Bankruptcy, Restructuring & Litigation
Blockchain, Smart Contracts & Digital Currencies
Business Litigation
Cannabis
Coronavirus Resource Center
Corporate
Crisis Management
Cybersecurity & Data Privacy
Delaware Corporate, LLC & Partnership Law
Design, Fashion & Luxury
E-Discovery & Records Management
Energy & Utilities
Environment & Energy
Financial Institutions
Government Affairs
Government Contracts & Global Trade
Government Investigations & White Collar Defense
Healthcare
Immigration
Impact Investing
Insurance Recovery, Litigation & Counseling
Intellectual Property
Labor & Employment Law
Life Sciences
Manufacturing
Products Liability, Mass Torts & Consumer Class Actions
Proptech
Public Finance 
Real Estate
Renewable Energy
Sports & Entertainment
Tax & Employee Benefits 
Technology Transactions
Transportation, Logistics & Supply Chain Management
Trusts, Estates & Private Clients 
Venture Capital & Emerging Growth Companies
  • Broadcasts
  • Events
  • News
  • Publications
  • View All Insights
Search By:
Insights Publication Magazine Pages
Main image for Delaware Court of Chancery Denies Italian Citizen’s Bid to Divest the Court of Jurisdiction Over a Matter Involving Delaware Limited Liability Partnerships
Publications|Alert

Delaware Court of Chancery Denies Italian Citizen’s Bid to Divest the Court of Jurisdiction Over a Matter Involving Delaware Limited Liability Partnerships

Delaware Law Update

12.29.2019

The Delaware Court of Chancery rejected a foreign citizen’s efforts to dismiss a lawsuit affecting a Delaware limited liability partnership in favor of his preferred forum in Italy. While AlixPartners confirmed that an American court’s legal authority is not absolute, a defendant bears the difficult burden of establishing the “limited circumstances” under which a Delaware court will not exercise jurisdiction over a dispute requiring the interpretation of foreign law. Where the dispute touches on the internal affairs of a Delaware entity, the burden is beyond daunting and approaching the realm of impossible.

Case Background

The plaintiff limited liability partnerships filed suit against the former managing director of their Italian subsidiary, arising out of the defendant’s purported efforts to download files from his work-issued computer prior to his termination. The lawsuit included claims for breach of contract related to the defendant’s employment agreement, declaratory relief as to the plaintiffs’ decisions to exercise their contractual rights to repurchase and terminate the defendant’s equity, misappropriation of trade secrets, and common-law conversion. The defendant moved to dismiss the lawsuit based on a lack of subject matter jurisdiction, with the Italian citizen arguing that a European Union regulation and provision of the Italian civil and labor procedure code divested the Court of Chancery of jurisdiction. The vice chancellor denied the motion but stayed the claim arising out of the defendant’s employment agreement and the cause of action for conversion.

As a general matter, a foreign law will not unilaterally divest an American court of the power to decide a dispute. An American court is fully capable of resolving foreign disputes, and “[t]here are only ‘limited circumstances’ in which Delaware courts ‘will not exercise subject matter jurisdiction over a dispute that is predicated on foreign law where the foreign state has vested jurisdiction exclusively in its own courts.’” This case was not one of them. Relying on precedent, the Court of Chancery found that the plaintiff’s claims were transitory in nature, so “the right and the remedy [were] not so inseparably united as to make the right dependent upon its being enforced in a particular tribunal.” Neither the European Union regulation nor the Italian labor law created the right or remedy sought to be enforced, and thus the plaintiff’s causes of action were not “inseparably united” with any foreign law requiring enforcement in a foreign tribunal.

Key Takeaways

AlixPartners confirms what most onlookers already suspect—the Court of Chancery will not refrain from deciding a matter within its jurisdiction, particularly a controversy implicating the internal affairs of a Delaware limited liability company. While the court exercised restraint in staying certain claims based on forum non conveniens, it did not hesitate in exercising jurisdiction over disputes involving the operation of a Delaware corporate entity. The plaintiff’s claims for relief did not stem from or arise out of foreign law. Although certain acts giving rise to the claims occurred on foreign soil, the rights and remedies underlying the lawsuit were not inseparable from European law such that the case must have been decided in Italy. To the contrary, the rights and remedies concerned matters of Delaware corporate governance that necessitated the Court of Chancery’s jurisdiction.

AlixPartners, LLP, et al. v. Giacomo Mori, C.A. No. 2019-0392-KSJM (Del. Ch. Nov. 26, 2019)

sidebar

pdfemail

Related People

Media item: Matthew J. Rifino
Matthew J. Rifino

Special Counsel

Related Services

Delaware Corporate, LLC & Partnership Law
Corporate
Subscribe to our Insights
McCarter & English, LLP
Copyright © 2021 McCarter & English, LLP. All Rights Reserved.
  • Login
  • Attorney Advertising
  • Privacy
  • Awards Methodology
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Sitemap

The McCarter & English, LLP website is for informational purposes only. We do not provide legal advice on this website. We can provide legal advice only to our clients in specific inquiries that they address to us. If you are interested in becoming a client, please contact us, but do not send any information about your specific legal question. We cannot serve as your lawyers until we establish an attorney-client relationship, which can occur only after we follow procedures within our firm and after we agree to the terms of the representation.

Accept Cancel